Challengers vs the big four: what AI tells Australians about personal lenders

Challengers vs the big four: what AI tells Australians about personal lenders

By

Ask ChatGPT, Claude, Copilot, Gemini, or Perplexity which lender to trust with a personal loan, and you'll get a short list of names. For a growing share of Australians, that list is where the search for a loan starts and ends.

Third Hemisphere's AI Authority Index™: Personal Lending shows who makes that list. This Australian-first index assesses how individual businesses are viewed by AI engines compared with their rivals. It starts with Australia's AUD 168 billion personal lending market. The Australian Financial Review reported the findings on 15 November 2026, in a story by James Eyers, "Banks on notice as Australians consult AI to help choose their lender".

The Australian Financial Review
As reported in The Australian Financial Review, 15 November 2026.

The Index puts 166 borrower questions to five AI engines and reads all 805 answers. Those questions cover personal loans, debt consolidation, car finance, credit cards, and short-term credit, across five stages of a borrower's decision:

  • learning
  • finding
  • comparing
  • choosing
  • buying

Of the 166 questions, 85 ask what to choose and 81 ask what to avoid. None names a lender. The engines named 124 lenders in their answers.

Why personal lending came first

Third Hemisphere chose personal lending for its first Index for two reasons:

  • Specialisation: the agency has spent over a decade working in financial services and fintech.
  • Demand: 87 percent of Australians now use AI search when deciding which financial services to buy.

The technology behind the Index has also gone well beyond one sector. CRISP™ has collected 195,689 AI answers across 159 sectors, recording 1,526,848 brand mentions and naming 60,206 distinct companies.

CommBank leads on both counts

Commonwealth Bank has the highest Presence of any lender at 46. That means the engines named it in 46 percent of answers. Its Reputation of 71 is also the highest on the Leaderboard, and its CRISP™ score of 54 is the joint highest, level with NAB. The engines both mention CommBank often and actively recommend it.

Outside CommBank, size doesn't predict Reputation

Several much smaller challenger lenders earned Reputation factors on par with CommBank, within the Index's margin of error, despite being named far less:

  • ING and OurMoneyMarket: 69
  • Plenti: 68
  • Harmoney: 67
  • NOW Finance: 66

Each of these sits well ahead of NAB (60), Westpac (56), and ANZ (42), even though the banks are far larger and named far more often.

Challengers also lead on specific questions:

  • Quick loans: the engines recommend MONEYME in 48 percent of the 25 answers about quick loans, and Harmoney in 40 percent.
  • Secured personal loans: Liberty is recommended in 60 percent of answers, and NOW Finance in 40 percent.
  • Customer service: ING is recommended in 68 percent of answers.

The gap between Presence and Reputation led Jeremy Liddle, Third Hemisphere's Executive Chair and the Index's author, to build the Star Chart. It plots both measures against each other and sorts lenders into six bands:

  • AI Famous: named often (in 30 percent of answers or more) and recommended.
  • Rising Stars: named sometimes (15 to 29 percent) and recommended.
  • Cult Favourites: rarely named (under 15 percent), but recommended when they are.
  • AI Infamous: named often, but cautioned against.
  • Bad Press: named sometimes, but cautioned against.
  • Off the Guest List: rarely named, and cautioned against when they are.

The bands have no numbered ranking. Each lender's place depends on how often the engines name it, and whether they recommend it more often than they caution against it.

In this edition, the lenders fall into the bands like this:

  • AI Famous: CommBank, NAB, and Westpac.
  • Rising Stars: ING and Macquarie.
  • Cult Favourites: 15 lenders, including Plenti, OurMoneyMarket, Harmoney, NOW Finance, Liberty, and MONEYME.
  • AI Infamous: ANZ alone, cautioned against more often than recommended in the answers that named it.
  • Off the Guest List: six lenders, Cash Converters, BOQ, Latitude Financial Services, St.George, Nimble, and Resimac.
  • On the line: Wallet Wizard, recommended and cautioned against equally, so it sits on the line between the bands.
The Star Chart for the AI Authority Index Personal Lending, Edition 1: the 28 lenders on the Leaderboard plotted by Presence and Reputation
The Star Chart: AI Authority Index™, Personal Lending, Edition 1. Source: Third Hemisphere.

Well-known names sit Under the Radar

A lender needs to be named in at least 30 answers to receive a reliable CRISP™ score and a place on the Leaderboard. Only 28 lenders cleared that bar. The other 96 sit Under the Radar, including well-known brands American Express, Afterpay, Zip, Klarna, Revolut, and Virgin Money.

Some come close. Swoosh was named in 27 answers, and BankSA, IMB, and Newcastle Permanent in 26 each. Each will move onto the Leaderboard once the engines name it in 30 or more answers.

Comparison sites shape the answers

The engines lean heavily on independent sources when borrowers choose a lender:

  • Comparison sites: Canstar is cited in 32 percent of answers, Finder in 30 percent, Money.com.au in 29 percent, and Mozo in 21 percent.
  • Regulator guidance: ASIC's Moneysmart is cited in 37 percent.

With smaller lenders matching CommBank's Reputation on a fraction of its mentions, Liddle says the results point to a lender's best route into AI recommendations: earning the endorsement of the independent sources the engines trust.

"The good news for every lender is that those sources can be influenced," Liddle said. "The engines form their opinions from comparison sites, ranking sites, regulators, and the media, so companies that earn real coverage, engage those sources well, and publish facts people can rely on can earn their way into the answers.

"The stakes are only rising. AI engines now sit between Australians and the decisions they make about their money, and when someone asks ChatGPT which lender to trust, the answer shapes their shortlist before they visit a comparison site or a bank's website."

Liddle told the AFR: "AI SEO is being invented right now. It's the wild west. And the companies that invest in it early will be light years in front when AI agents actively start making decisions on behalf of buyers."

Every lender now has a job to do

Hannah Moreno, Founder and CEO, and Jeremy Liddle, Executive Chair, Third Hemisphere
L to R: Hannah Moreno, Founder and CEO, and Jeremy Liddle, Executive Chair, Third Hemisphere.

Hannah Moreno, Founder and CEO of Third Hemisphere, said trust has always been the currency of financial services.

"Trust has been the currency of financial services long before I founded Third Hemisphere in 2014 with MONEYME as our first client," Moreno said. "What is different now is the AI engines decide who deserves this trust as guardians of the information we consume about brands. Third Hemisphere has spent over a decade building that trust for the companies we represent across multiple channels, so evolving to measure it in AI answers was a natural next step.

"Looking at the results of our first index, every featured lender now has a clear job to do. Challengers already win the engines' trust when they're found, so their task is to be found more often, while three of the big four need to change what the engines say about them. Both are fixable, and we're happy to show any lender how."

How CRISP™ measures AI authority

CRISP™ defines each sector's customer segments, products, benefits, harms, and buyer stages. It then puts the resulting questions to the five engines and analyses every answer. Each lender gets a score out of 100, weighted across five factors:

  • Consensus (10 percent): when one engine names the company, whether the others name it too.
  • Reputation (25 percent): whether the engines recommend the company more often than they caution against it. A score of 50 means the two are even.
  • Influence (25 percent): whether independent sources stand behind what the engines say, and how many.
  • Source (15 percent): whether the company's own website holds up as the record of what is true about it, and whether AI can read and quote it.
  • Presence (25 percent): the share of answers that name the company.

The factors build on the Interactive Advertising Bureau's measurement standards and other published research. No company can pay to be included or placed, and Third Hemisphere's clients are measured on the same instrument as everyone else. MONEYME, a Third Hemisphere client, appears on the Leaderboard with its readings published unchanged. The full method is at thirdhemisphere.agency/crisp-methodology.

The Index's results are open data under CC BY 4.0, with a DOI on Zenodo, and are also published on GitHub, Hugging Face, and Kaggle.

See the full Index, or check your own company

Read the full AI Authority Index™: Personal Lending.

See how AI engines describe your own company with a free AI Authority Check.

About the author. Jeremy Liddle is the Executive Chair of Third Hemisphere and the author of the AI Authority Index™. He designed CRISP™, Third Hemisphere's AI visibility measurement software behind the Index, and leads its development.

About Third Hemisphere. Third Hemisphere is the integrated PR, marketing, AI Authority & Visibility, and investor relations agency helping ambitious companies grow, from Sydney, Melbourne, and Singapore. Founded in Sydney in 2014, it is a Certified B Corporation and publishes the AI Authority Index™.

How to cite. Third Hemisphere, AI Authority Index™, Personal Lending, Edition 1, published 1 October 2026, updated 12 November 2026. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23809586

CRISP™ and AI Authority Index™ are trade marks of Third Hemisphere Pty Ltd.